What Arguments Do Insurance Companies Use to Reduce Injury Claims?

Last updated:

In our experience, insurance companies most often make two arguments. The first is that the injured person was all or partly at fault. The second is that the collision didn’t cause the injuries, either because there wasn’t enough force or because the injuries pre-dated the crash. Early offers are also often low.

Key takeaways

  • The two most common arguments are shared fault and causation.
  • Objective evidence, such as a witness statement or video, is the best response to a fault argument.
  • Early offers are often low, and a statement given on the day of a crash may not reflect injuries that develop later.

How do insurers argue fault?

At-fault insurance companies usually take the word of their own insured at face value, so a driver’s account is often the starting point for a fault argument. The best response is objective evidence to the contrary, such as a witness statement or video. California’s pure comparative negligence rule means shared fault reduces your recovery but doesn’t bar it.

How do insurers argue that the crash didn’t cause the injuries?

Insurers sometimes argue that the collision didn’t involve enough force to cause the injuries, or that the injuries pre-dated the incident. Medical records, the timing of your symptoms, and a treating provider’s explanation help address both arguments.

Why do insurers ask for pre-accident medical records?

Insurers sometimes ask for extensive pre-accident medical records. We provide records that are relevant to the claim.

Why are early settlement offers often low?

In our experience, early offers are often low because insurers test how far the client and the attorney are willing to take a case. An early offer may also come before treatment is finished, so it can’t reflect the full picture of your injuries.

Why can a statement on the day of a crash hurt a claim?

Adrenaline can delay the perception of injury, and soft tissue injuries usually develop over the days after an incident. A statement given that day, such as saying you aren’t injured, often doesn’t account for that progression.

Read next: First 24 Hours After a Crash and How Fault Is Decided. To talk about your own situation, see our Car Accident Lawyer page. Official agency links are in Official Resources, the statutes are in California Laws at a Glance, and definitions are in the glossary.

Frequently asked questions

Can an insurer deny my claim because I had a prior injury?

A prior injury doesn’t automatically end a claim, but insurers may argue that your injuries pre-dated the crash. Medical records and the timing of your symptoms matter, so talk to an attorney.

Should I accept the first offer?

Early offers are often low and may come before the full extent of your injuries is known. Once you accept a settlement you typically can’t ask for more, so talk to an attorney first.

More questions? See our FAQ page or the Attorney Insights Q&A.

Where can I learn more?

This article from Carpio & Turner Capstone Legal, APC is general information, not legal advice, and laws change. Every case is different, and results depend on the facts. Attorney advertising. [Reviewed by: Michael Turner, 11/16/2026]

Get Your Free Case Review